Ignore the Negative Gearing Noise

negative gearing

Ignore the Negative Gearing Noise

There’s a lot of nervousness among property investors at the moment.

I’m not talking about the softening in property prices either, because the savvy ones know that you should act while others are hesitating.

I’m talking about the proposed scrapping of negative gearing provisions for existing property that Labor will seemingly make a reality should they win the next election in May.

A lot of would-be investors I’m speaking to are worried, but I’m here to tell you to ignore all of the noise about negative gearing.

It doesn’t matter. It shouldn’t concern you. And really, in the scheme of things, it won’t impact you.

Here’s why.


It’s not a strategy for you

Negative gearing is a moment in time.

It provides some modest taxation benefits for the short-term, allowing you to offset the ongoing income losses of having a rental property that costs you more than it brings in.

Let’s break that down.

Your investment loses you money, and so you get a bit of a leg-up from the Tax Man.

That doesn’t sound like a fantastic investment to me.

It sounds like a short-sighted gamble where you’re banking on a hope that what you’ve bought will increase enough in value to make up for the money you’ve had to pour into it.

It means you’re buying speculatively.

You’re essentially paying to secure the investment, potentially haemorrhaging money while you’re holding it, and praying that you can sell it on to someone else for more than you paid.

The smarter thing to do is to think long-term.

That’s what sophisticated investors do.

They make smart buying decisions and hold – preferably as part of a 15-year plan.

Part of that smart buying is picking an investment that doesn’t rely on negative gearing.

Most well-bought investment properties are neutral within three to five years, and preferably positive not long after that.

Educated investors hold their ground and focus on the big picture.

They don’t roll the dice and hope for the best.

This isn’t the pokies.

They work with experts like buyer’s agents to source the best deals with the absolute best prospects that can deliver solid growth.

They have a strategy to maximise their returns without having to speculate.


The plan doesn’t work anyway

Labor hopes its scrapping of negative gearing will improve housing affordability.

They feel that by giving “tax breaks” to property investors, it stimulates activity and drives up house prices.

It’s not a new idea.

In fact, this is simply history repeating – one from long enough ago that many seem to have forgotten how it played out.

In 1985, the newly minted Hawke Labor Government abolished negative gearing on rental properties.

They, too, believed it would aide housing affordability by evening the playing field, so owner-occupiers could get into the market at the expense of landlords.

You know what happened? Rents went up. With less rental stock in the market, supply dwindled while demand remained high and prices increased.

At the same time, the promised relaxing of house prices didn’t really eventuate.

Interest rates were also in double digits, which made getting a mortgage and paying it off an unrealistic prospect for first homebuyers.

At the same time, they had less money to save because they were forking out more in rent.

Negative gearing was reinstated pretty quickly.


Change will help the market

Let’s say Labor wins the election, which most polling indicates is a strong reality.

They scrap negative gearing – except for investors buying brand new property; part of the strategy to seemingly boost housing supply.

You’re a savvy, strategic-thinking property investor who focuses on the long-term, remember? So, it doesn’t really matter to you.

But here’s what would likely happen.

Rents will increase. We know from basic economics of supply and demand that this is likely to happen.

Supply is already tight, with new housing starts falling because big developers are nervous about softer prices, the global economy and lending restrictions.

Should mum and dad landlords who need negative gearing decide that it’s not worth their while and sell up, more supply will be ripped out.

Rental demand remains extremely thanks to population growth and low levels of first-time buyers in the market.

And, so, rental prices will go up.

For strategic investors, fewer first-time buyers means less competition at the affordable end of the market – the price pocket that deliver now-higher rents will be attractive prospects.

Given that Labor’s plan means negative gearing will only apply to brand-new properties, we’re likely to see a lock of speculators out and about.

They’ll target brand new builds, which will be overpriced as a result.

Those investors with their focus elsewhere, on properties with fairly ordinary investment fundamentals, will again lower competition among savvy buyers like yourself.

You’ll be away from the feeding frenzy, targeting well-located property with good capital growth prospects for the long-term.


We could see a mini boom

The likely Labor election result will see a lot of change.

There will be a change in regime in Canberra with the focus shifting away a bit from getting the Budget back to surplus and towards investing in big-ticket infrastructure, health and education.

There will be an uptick in consumer confidence. Major sectors like construction will likely also enjoy renewed activity.

And, I predict, there will be a rush of investors keen to take advantage of the grandfathering clause in the negative gearing changes.

They will buy while they can, to lock in the tax break for established properties – not that negative gearing is their motivation, but it does help in the first few years of owning an investment property.

This may drive a short mini property boom, helping to kick along the recovery phase for markets like Sydney and Melbourne where prices have fallen but, in some cases, appear to be beginning to plateau.

So, let’s sum up.

If you’re savvy, negative gearing changes won’t matter to you, but they will see rents increase and your competition for good investment opportunities dry up.

And the prospect of the changes between now and then will likely spark a rush of activity that will help markets bounce back.

All that’s left for you to do is keep your eye on the long-term prize, buy well now, and position yourself for the best returns in the years ahead.


free property investment ebook

High-Performance Property Investment in
5 Simple Steps

In this free guide, you will learn how to Implement the same strategies that led me to build a $3.5 million dollar portfolio in less than six years. – Daniel Walsh

Related Post


Respecting your Privacy

Your Property Your Wealth Pty Ltd (YPYW) is committed to supporting the Australian Privacy Principles for all fair handling of Personal Information which set clear standards for the collection, use, disclosure, storage of and access to Personal Information collected during the course of business operations and compliance with the Privacy Act 1988 (Commonwealth) and its amendments (the Act), and the Australian Privacy Principles (APPs) set out in that Act. You can see the full text of the APPs online at the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner’s website at:


Personal Information means your name, mailing or residential address, telephone number, email address and other transaction and registration details including the company you work for and your role and financial information, including credit card information and information collected from credit reporting agencies.

Our respect for your rights to the privacy of your personal information is paramount.  We have policies and procedures in place to ensure that all personal information, no matter how or where it is obtained, is handled sensitively, securely and in accordance with the APPs.

This Privacy Policy sets out:

  • What sort of personal information is collected and stored;
  • How information is collected and used;
  • What happens if you choose not to provide the required information; and
  • How you can request access to the personal information we hold about you.

From time to time it may be necessary for YPYW to review and revise this Privacy Policy. We reserve the right to change our policy at any time. Amendments or replacements of the Privacy Policy will be posted on our website.

Collection of Your Personal Information

We only collect personal information relevant to our business relationship with you so that we can provide our services and products. We may collect your personal information:

  • directly from you including via telephone, email or facsimile;
  • when your register on our website;
  • when you place an order or service request with us;
  • where you access and interact with our website;
  • from other sources including a third party such as credit reporting; and
  • any correspondence we receive from you.

Is your personal information secure

Where you submit personal information, we manage it by using up-to-date techniques and processes that meet current industry standards to ensure that your personal information is kept secure and confidential. We also take measures to destroy or permanently de-identify personal information if it is no longer required.

Use and Disclosure of Personal Information

You acknowledge and consent that by providing your personal information to us that we may use and disclose your personal information for the purpose for which it was collected or for a related or ancillary purpose such as:

  • supply of our services and products to you in accordance with our Terms and Conditions and any agreement entered into with you, to facilitate, process, carry out and respond to your request;
  • to our third party service providers to assist us in providing and improving our services and products to you and developing, improving and marketing our services and products to you;
  • for regulatory reporting and compliance with our legal obligations, to various regulatory bodies and law enforcement officials and agencies to protect against fraud and for related security purposes;
  • to the seller or supplier of any products to you for the purpose of ascertaining and obtaining any information required to perform our services for you;
  • to identify you and conduct appropriate checks, including credit checks;
  • set up, administer and manage our services and products and systems, including the management and administration of an account;
  • to train and develop our staff to better provide services to you;
  • to contact you; and
  • to our successors and/or assigns

What happens if you do not want to disclose personal information?

You have no obligation to provide any personal information requested by us, but if you choose to withhold personal information, we may not be able to provide you with the products and services that depend on the collection of that information.

Removing your personal information

You may contact us at any time in writing and request that we remove and delete your stored personal information.

Providing Personal Information About Another Person

You represent to us that where you provide personal information to us about another person, you are authorised to provide that information to us, and that you will inform that person who we are, how we use and disclose their information, and that they can gain access to that information.

Linked Sites

YPYW’s website may contain links to websites which are owned or operated by other parties. You should make enquiries as to the privacy policies of these parties. We are not responsible for information, or the privacy practices of such websites.

How can you access your personal information?

You may in writing request access to personal information that we hold about you. We will provide you with access to personal information in accordance with the Act and APPs and we may not grant you access to the personal information that we hold where the APPs allow us to do so. If you are refused access to information, we will provide you with reasons for the refusal in writing.

How to contact us

If you have any questions in relation to privacy, please contact us on 0490 912 045 or email Daniel Walsh – admin@ypyw.com.au. For more information about privacy law please visit http://www.oaic.gov.au/privacy.

High-Performance Property Investment in 5 Simple Steps

In this free guide, you will learn how to Implement the same strategies that led me to build a $3.5 million dollar portfolio in less than six years. – Daniel Walsh