Why guaranteeing first-home deposits makes financial sense

A re-elected Coalition Government will guarantee deposits for first home buyers it was announced on Sunday.

scott morrisonThe policy, called the First Home Loan Deposit Scheme, was something that many of us in the industry expected at some point in the lead-up to the election.

Why is that?

Well, it creates a key point of difference with the Australian Labor Party’s plans to restrict negative gearing and reduce the Capital Gains Tax discount.

However, a policy to help more first home buyers into the market by assisting with deposits also makes more financial sense than one that potentially reduces property values wholesale.

Winning at any cost

Unsurprisingly, a mere few hours after the policy was unveiled, the ALP announced they would match it, which just goes to show that winning the election is more important to a potential Shorten Government than being able to afford any of its policies.

What many people won’t read in the media this week is that assisting first home buyers into the property market has been around for decades in one form or another.

While the latest statistics show that first home buyer activity is at historical averages, there is no doubt that saving 20 per cent has always been a struggle for most first-timers.

That’s why underwriting a percentage of the deposit will not only help more young people become property owners sooner it will also save them having to pay for Lenders Mortgage Insurance or LMI.

LMI is a fee that is charged on loans that have deposits of less than 20 per cent and is usually capitalised (or added) on to a home loan.

Of course, that means that the borrower is paying off that additional figure, with interest, for years to come.

So, the scheme saves first home buyers having to fork out for an insurance policy that at the end of the day protects banks and not borrowers.

Scheme won’t drive up prices

Also, there has already been much talk about how the scheme will “drive up prices”.

Seemingly, if first home buyers have $50,000 “more” money to spend, they will automatically pay more for a property.

Of course, they don’t because the scheme is a loan and not a financial gift.

Also, while detail on the scheme is still scant, my understanding is that there will be a stringent approval process, which probably includes loan pre-approval limits.

It has already been announced that there will also be limits on property prices as well, similar to what is already in place for many first home buyer concessions and grants in each State and Territory.

There has long been conjecture about whether grants or schemes like these drive up prices.

However, let’s consider when the First Home Owners Boost came into play to boost the property market during the GFC, which was for about a year from October 2008.

That was one of the most generous grants ever announced with first home buyers receiving $14,000 to buy established properties and $21,000 to buy new ones.

Does anyone remember what Sydney dwelling prices were doing back in, say, 2010 to 2012?

According to CoreLogic, they fell about 3.7 per cent.

In fact, dwelling values fell by about 6.5 per cent nationally, including in every State and Territory.

This week, some elements of the media would like us to ignore these statistics as it doesn’t marry with their narrative.

Ditto, with the last time that negative gearing was changed in the 1980s.


I’d rather stick with my understanding of what has happened before – and what is likely to happen again.

High-Performance Property Investment in
5 Simple Steps

In this free guide, you will learn how to Implement the same strategies that led me to build a $3.5 million dollar portfolio in less than six years. – Daniel Walsh

Related Post


Respecting your Privacy

Your Property Your Wealth Pty Ltd (YPYW) is committed to supporting the Australian Privacy Principles for all fair handling of Personal Information which set clear standards for the collection, use, disclosure, storage of and access to Personal Information collected during the course of business operations and compliance with the Privacy Act 1988 (Commonwealth) and its amendments (the Act), and the Australian Privacy Principles (APPs) set out in that Act. You can see the full text of the APPs online at the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner’s website at:


Personal Information means your name, mailing or residential address, telephone number, email address and other transaction and registration details including the company you work for and your role and financial information, including credit card information and information collected from credit reporting agencies.

Our respect for your rights to the privacy of your personal information is paramount.  We have policies and procedures in place to ensure that all personal information, no matter how or where it is obtained, is handled sensitively, securely and in accordance with the APPs.

This Privacy Policy sets out:

  • What sort of personal information is collected and stored;
  • How information is collected and used;
  • What happens if you choose not to provide the required information; and
  • How you can request access to the personal information we hold about you.

From time to time it may be necessary for YPYW to review and revise this Privacy Policy. We reserve the right to change our policy at any time. Amendments or replacements of the Privacy Policy will be posted on our website.

Collection of Your Personal Information

We only collect personal information relevant to our business relationship with you so that we can provide our services and products. We may collect your personal information:

  • directly from you including via telephone, email or facsimile;
  • when your register on our website;
  • when you place an order or service request with us;
  • where you access and interact with our website;
  • from other sources including a third party such as credit reporting; and
  • any correspondence we receive from you.

Is your personal information secure

Where you submit personal information, we manage it by using up-to-date techniques and processes that meet current industry standards to ensure that your personal information is kept secure and confidential. We also take measures to destroy or permanently de-identify personal information if it is no longer required.

Use and Disclosure of Personal Information

You acknowledge and consent that by providing your personal information to us that we may use and disclose your personal information for the purpose for which it was collected or for a related or ancillary purpose such as:

  • supply of our services and products to you in accordance with our Terms and Conditions and any agreement entered into with you, to facilitate, process, carry out and respond to your request;
  • to our third party service providers to assist us in providing and improving our services and products to you and developing, improving and marketing our services and products to you;
  • for regulatory reporting and compliance with our legal obligations, to various regulatory bodies and law enforcement officials and agencies to protect against fraud and for related security purposes;
  • to the seller or supplier of any products to you for the purpose of ascertaining and obtaining any information required to perform our services for you;
  • to identify you and conduct appropriate checks, including credit checks;
  • set up, administer and manage our services and products and systems, including the management and administration of an account;
  • to train and develop our staff to better provide services to you;
  • to contact you; and
  • to our successors and/or assigns

What happens if you do not want to disclose personal information?

You have no obligation to provide any personal information requested by us, but if you choose to withhold personal information, we may not be able to provide you with the products and services that depend on the collection of that information.

Removing your personal information

You may contact us at any time in writing and request that we remove and delete your stored personal information.

Providing Personal Information About Another Person

You represent to us that where you provide personal information to us about another person, you are authorised to provide that information to us, and that you will inform that person who we are, how we use and disclose their information, and that they can gain access to that information.

Linked Sites

YPYW’s website may contain links to websites which are owned or operated by other parties. You should make enquiries as to the privacy policies of these parties. We are not responsible for information, or the privacy practices of such websites.

How can you access your personal information?

You may in writing request access to personal information that we hold about you. We will provide you with access to personal information in accordance with the Act and APPs and we may not grant you access to the personal information that we hold where the APPs allow us to do so. If you are refused access to information, we will provide you with reasons for the refusal in writing.

How to contact us

If you have any questions in relation to privacy, please contact us on 0490 912 045 or email Daniel Walsh – admin@ypyw.com.au. For more information about privacy law please visit http://www.oaic.gov.au/privacy.

High-Performance Property Investment in 5 Simple Steps

In this free guide, you will learn how to Implement the same strategies that led me to build a $3.5 million dollar portfolio in less than six years. – Daniel Walsh